Source: Instagram @cheynotshy
Many fans agreed that Cheyenne was a poor choice for the open slot. GlitzAndGrit echoed the sentiment, writing “I’m not liking this decision. Not only is she not from the 16&P/TM shows, she was boring on MTV’s Challenge (never watched Are You The One so can’t speak to that), and she’s not even a teen mom.”
The fans seemed upset to have to meet and grow attached to a whole new mom. User chrissycakes8726 agreed, “WTH! What happened with Mackenzie McKee??? This is bullsh*t! This girl isn’t a part of this franchise in any way shape or form. She also had her first kid at 24…that’s not even close to a teen Mom.”
Though her “advanced” age has been unsettling to longtime fans of the franchise, the biggest controversy surrounding Cheyenne dates back to her teen years!